Lobster & Crab Rolls at Luke’s Lobster – NYC

lobster roll @ luke's lobster

A few weeks ago, I told David I was in the mood for lobster and he told me to go find another boyfriend. (Oh no he didn’t!) So I took matters into my own hands and went to Luke’s Lobster myself. Much faster than getting a new boyfriend.

I love lobster rolls, but they’re pricey stuff, usually around $27 in this town. At Luke’s Lobster, lobster rolls are $14, practically half the going rate. The price is a reflection of the owner’s connections. Luke Holden grew up in Maine, and his dad, Jeff Holden, owns Portland Shellfish, a seafood processing company. As a result, their relationship with local lobstermen enables them to ship the lobster directly from the docks of Maine to the East Village.

At Luke’s I ordered a small Lobster Roll ($8) since I wanted to try one of the other seafood rolls. The small is referred to as snack size, and it’s exactly that. When I first saw it, I thought it was a joke, but the tiny roll — toasted and buttery — was chock full of fresh knuckle and claw meat with only the tiniest bit of mayonnaise and a sprinkle of celery salt. It’s all meat, no filler; the exact polar opposite of the luscious mayoriffic lobster rolls from Pearl Oyster Bar. It was surprisingly satisfying, but next time I’ll probably ask for a little more mayo and lemon. The great thing about Luke’s Lobster is that you can always add more mayo if you want it. Taking out mayo is problematic.

crab roll @ luke's lobster

The Crab Roll ($5/small) was just as fresh and delicious, with chunks of sweet crab. Again, the small order was tiny, but it was a whole lot of crab. Well worth it, even if your boyfriend didn’t take you.

Luke’s Lobster
93 East 7th Street (betw 1st & Ave A; map)
New York, NY‎ 10009

There are 14 comments

Add yours
  1. Nicholas

    Hahaha, this post just screams passive-aggression. To be fair, those sandwiches look comically small. I’m not sure how I’d feel for 4 bites costing $8.

  2. someguy

    LOL come on David, lobster is not that much! It is a small price to pay to make your woman happy. Is the regular roll twice the size?

  3. bionicgrrrl

    @Nicholas – Trust me, I am never passive with aggression. If you ever met my BF, he would tell you. As for size, it is small, but compared to other places the price is reasonable.

    @someguy – In David’s defense, he takes me to a lot of fancy restaurants. And yeah, the small is basically half a full roll.

  4. Steve

    i went for the 7th Street Food Fest and received the snack size. it was great. you have to live in nyc to realize it is a good deal for what you get.

    is david kosher? if so, LL is reason to break it. (this coming from a bad jew.)

  5. someguy

    My friend lives a couple of blocks away. I will try the lobster roll the next time I visit.

    Ah so David treats you well. Now I hear bells in the distance.

  6. bionicgrrrl

    @Steve – No, he’s not kosher, just extremely picky, and also a former vegan.

    @someguy – Far, far in the distance.

    @wonders – It’s very small, definitely less than 5 inches.

  7. ®å

    ive been to maine; the rolls there are really big. BUT the people are creepy… like steven king… (have you seen the controversy w/ the rich lady w/ no real maine connection trying to take over the lobster shack business?)

  8. bionicgrrrl

    @uken – I’m sure someone will one day. Lobster rolls are popping up everywhere.

    @®å – Never met anyone creepy from Maine before, and haven’t heard about the Lobster Shack drama.

Post a new comment